Abstract
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Differentiation of malignant from benign head and neck lesions is often very difficult on imaging studies, especially in patients with treated cancer. We evaluated the feasibility and reproducibility of perfusion CT (CTP) after enhanced head and neck CT and attempted to differentiate benign from malignant processes.
METHODS: CTP was attempted in 17 patients after head and neck contrast-enhanced CT. Data were postprocessed by using deconvolution-based perfusion analysis. Ipsilateral and contralateral internal, external, and common carotid arteries were used as arterial input vessels. Postprocessing-generated maps showed mean transit time (MTT), blood volume, blood flow, and capillary permeability surface product. Two readers independently placed regions of interest through the primary site, salivary glands, thyroid gland, paraspinous muscles, muscles of mastication, sternocleidomastoid muscle, base of tongue, and subcutaneous fat. One reader repeated the measurements on separate dates. Data were statistically analyzed, and histologic specimens were obtained.
RESULTS: CTP was not possible in four patients, and one was lost to follow-up. Of the remaining 12, five had cancer, and seven had benign processes. We found no significant interreader or intrareader differences and no significant difference between various input vessels. Differentiation between malignant and nonmalignant lesions was most reliable by using MTTs. Measurements were comparable to those in the literature.
CONCLUSION: CTP after enhanced head and neck CT is feasible, except perhaps at the laryngeal level. It appears to be reader independent and reproducible regardless of the input vessel. CTP shows promise in distinguishing benign and malignant processes, primarily by means of MTTs.
CT and MR imaging are routinely used to diagnose and stage cancers of the head and neck and to evaluate treated patients with suspected recurrence. Reliance on anatomic imaging has its drawbacks, as early lesion detection remains challenging, and nonneoplastic processes can morphologically mimic large lesions. This challenge is further compounded in patients who have undergone surgery or irradiation and who have a background of anatomic distortion, which can preclude the early detection of recurrent neoplasm. Tissue biopsy for pathologic confirmation is invasive, associated with a risk of hemorrhage and infection, and not infrequently limited by sampling error; however, it remains a necessary step in many cases. Several approaches have been devised to perform functional imaging to overcome the limitations of anatomic imaging. Most notable among these is the use of positron emission tomography (PET). However, PET is not widely available and represents an extra step with substantial added cost. Perfusion CT (CTP) is a new approach that shows promise in overcoming some of these limitations.
Induction of neovascularity is a feature of malignant neoplasms that is essential in sustaining these tumors and allowing for their rapid growth. In theory, perfusion-based imaging is used to take advantage of neovascularity to discriminate benign structures from aggressive lesions and might help with the early detection of malignancy, the prediction of tumor behavior, and the assessment of responses to therapy.
CT and MR imaging perfusion parameters can be generated by using a number of approaches, which can be grouped into two major methods: compartmental analysis and deconvolution-based methods. Detailed mathematical and physical principles behind these methods of calculation are available for review in the literature (1–6). In compartmental analysis, one considers the intravascular and extravascular spaces as a single compartment, which is valid for the time points before the arrival of the contrast medium into the draining veins of the tissue of interest. Blood flow is calculated from the maximal slope of the tissue concentration-time curve or from its peak height and normalized to the arterial input function (1, 3). Deconvolution uses arterial and tissue time-attenuation curves to calculate the impulse residue function for the tissue of interest, which is usually constrained to comprise a plateau followed by a single exponential decay. The height of the function gives the tissue blood flow and the area under the curve determines the relative blood volume (1, 3, 7).
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the feasibility of CTP in the head and neck and to evaluate interreader and intrareader reproducibility. The results from various arterial input vessels were compared for significant differences. We looked into the reliability of performing CTP after regular enhanced CT and compared the results with those in recent publications. In addition, results from benign and malignant processes were compared.
Methods
Patients
We prospectively attempted CTP in 17 consecutive patients with known or suspected head and neck neoplasm between October and December 2003 as part of a pilot feasibility study that was approved by our institutional review board. In all patients, biopsy was performed after the imaging study.
Imaging
CTP scans were obtained by using a multisection scanner (Light speed Ultra; GE Medical Systems, Milwaukee, WI) after we performed regular enhanced CT of the head and neck. For this study, 100 mL of contrast agent was injected at a rate of 2 mL/second and images were acquired from the skull base to the thoracic inlet with 2.5-mm contiguous sections. CTP was attempted in 17 patients 5 minutes later. The initial regular diagnostic CT scans served as localizers for CTP, and a few minutes were needed to review the images and position for the CTP study. Five minutes was selected to standardize the time between the two studies. For the CTP study, patients received a power injection of nonionic iodinated contrast agent (iohexol; Omnipaque, Amersham Health Inc., Princeton, NJ) (40 mL, 300 mg/mL) at 4 mL/s and were scanned to acquire four contiguous 5-mm-thick CT images every second for 50 seconds at the predetermined levels of interest. The levels of interest were centered on the area of gross anatomic distortion when a lesion was identified. For lesions larger than 10 mm in diameter, the levels with the largest enhancing portions were selected. In patients with no defined lesion on the regular enhanced CT scans, perfusion images were obtained through the areas that were clinically suspicious.
Data Processing
The data were postprocessed by using a commercial software package based on a deconvolution-based technique (Perfusion 2 software package, Advantage Windows workstation; GE Medical Systems). Two readers (Z.R., R.A.) independently performed the postprocessing after agreeing on the structures of interest and on the size of the region of interest (ROI), (i.e., >25 mm2). ROIs were placed in available arterial input vessels and in the internal jugular vein to generate contrast-enhanced curves. In each patient, each reader generated three sets of calculations, as different available input arterial vessels were selected for each calculation. The vessels were the internal carotid artery (ICA) on the same side of the lesion, the contralateral ICA, and the external carotid artery (ECA) on the side on which it was better visualized. In some patients, only the common carotid artery could be used as the arterial input vessel.
The data were processed into maps for each arterial input that represented blood volume mean transit time (MTT) (in seconds), blood volume (in milliliters per 100 g), blood flow (in milliliters per 100 g per minute), and capillary permeability surface product (CP, in milliliters per 100 g per minute) (Figs 1–4). Blood flow was defined as the volume flow rate of blood through the vasculature in a tissue. Blood volume was the volume of blood within the vasculature of a tissue that was flowing and not stagnant. MTT was the average time taken by the blood elements to traverse the vasculature from the arterial end to the venous end. CP was the product of permeability and the total surface area of capillary endothelium in a unit mass of tissue representing the total diffusional flux across all capillaries. It was calculated according to the following equation: CP = −blood flow[ln (1 − E)], where E is the extraction fraction (the fraction of contrast material that leaks into the extravascular space from the intravascular space).
Patient 8 with atypical vascular proliferation of the vocal cord.
A, Contrast-enhanced neck CT scan shows a mass in the left true vocal cord. ROIs 9 and 11–13 are in the lesion, and ROI 10 is in the contralateral vocal cord.
B, CTP functional map shows a relatively low blood flow of 26–32 mL/100 g/min in the lesion in the left vocal cord. Right vocal cord has blood flow of 26 mL/100 g/min. Scale from red to blue corresponds to decreasing flow.
C, CTP functional map shows that the lesion has a relatively long MTT of 6.9–11.6 seconds. Scale from red to blue corresponds to increasing MTT.
Patient 3 with surgically treated acinic cell cancer of the parotid gland.
A, Rater 1. Contrast-enhanced neck CT scan shows a mass in the suboccipital subcutaneous fat (arrow) that was a suspected metastatic lymph node. Histology showed fat necrosis and chronic inflammation. ROIs are placed on the lesion (1) and on the masseter (3) and paraspinal (5) muscles.
B, Rater 2. CTP functional map shows relatively low blood flow of 24.9 mL/100 g/min in the lesion (arrow, ROI 1) and shows ROIs in the masseter (4) and paraspinal (8 and 9) muscles. Scale from red to blue corresponds to decreasing flow.
C, Rater 2. CTP functional map shows that the lesion (arrow, ROI 1) has a relatively long MTT of 10.5 seconds and shows ROIs in the masseter (4) and paraspinal (8 and 9) muscles. Scale from red to blue corresponds to increasing MTT.
Patient 12 with primary gingival squamous cell cancer.
A, Contrast-enhanced neck CT scan shows a mass on both sides of the left mandibular body (arrows).
B, Lesion is more conspicuous on the CTP functional map, which reveals a high blood flow of 96–144 mL/100 g/min. Scale from red to blue corresponds to decreasing flow.
C, CTP functional map shows that the lesion has a short MTT of 2.1–5.4 seconds. Scale from red to blue corresponds to increasing MTT. The ROIs were placed within the lesion (8 and 9), paraspinal muscles (10), and left parotid gland (11).
Patient 13 with recurrent laryngeal squamous cell cancer previously treated with radiation.
A, Contrast-enhanced neck CT scan shows thickening and diffuse enhancement of supralaryngeal structures. ROIs 1 and 2 are placed bilaterally in the abnormality. Both sampled sites were positive for recurrence on histology. ROI 4 is in the left sternocleidomastoid muscle.
B, CTP functional map reveals areas of increased perfusion with blood flows of 67 and 77 mL/100 g/min. Scale from red to blue corresponds to decreasing flow.
C, CTP functional map shows short MTTs of 2.5 and 3.4 seconds in the abnormality. Scale from red to blue corresponds to decreasing MTT.
The readers subsequently obtained ROIs through the primary site (lesion or suspected lesion) and through other structures that appeared normal on regular enhanced CT scans of the head and neck: salivary glands (parotid or submandibular glands), thyroid gland, paraspinous muscles, muscles of mastication, sternocleidomastoid, base of the tongue, and subcutaneous fat (Figs 1–4). One reader performed measurements twice, 2 weeks apart, by using the ipsilateral ICA as the input vessel. The structures of interest were not available on all scans due to limited coverage on CTP. The average values of blood volume, blood flow, MTT, and CP were obtained for the primary site, salivary glands, thyroid gland, paraspinous muscles, muscles of mastication, sternocleidomastoid, base of the tongue and subcutaneous fat.
Statistical Analysis
We compared the measurements obtained from different readers, and different input arterial vessels for each of the perfusion parameters (MTT, blood volume, blood flow, CP) and for each of the measured structures (primary site, salivary glands, thyroid gland, paraspinous muscles, muscles of mastication, sternocleidomastoid, base of the tongue, and subcutaneous fat). This was done to evaluate for statistically significant interreader differences and for statistically significant differences between CTP with ICA-versus-ECA arterial vessel input or a difference when the side of the input vessel was changed. In addition, differences between malignant and benign lesions and normal structures were assessed. Comparison with published measurements of perfusion parameters was performed. Statistical analysis of variability was determined by one-way analysis of variance. Statistical analysis of the observed differences between various tissues was performed with the unpaired t test.
Results
CTP was feasible in 13 (76%) of 17 attempts and in two (40%) of five attempts at the laryngeal level. In four patients, CTP was not feasible: In one, bolus timing was poor, and in three, the studies were limited by laryngeal motion, which resulted in unsatisfactory enhancement curves. Of the remaining 13 patients, five had histologically confirmed new cancers or recurrences, seven had benign findings, and one was lost to follow-up. Therefore, our study group included 12 patients (eight men and four women; age range, 17–80 years; mean age, 55 years). Table 1 summarizes the patients’ characteristics and diagnoses.
Summary of the study group
The measurements were analyzed for reproducibility between different readers, the same reader on two occasions, and various arterial input vessels. Table 2 summarizes the results of this analysis. Application of the one-way analysis of variance revealed no statistically significant interreader difference, and we found no significant difference between CTP with ICA-versus-ECA input, between measurements of one reader on two occasions, or between the ipsilateral and contralateral ICA as the input artery. Although the statistical test failed to show a significant difference in these mentioned parameters, it was able to reveal significant differences in measurements between patients for most structures. The primary-site lesions included retromolar trigone squamous cell cancer, gingival squamous cell cancer, squamous cell cancer on the floor of the mouth, recurrent squamous cell cancer of the larynx, orbital alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma, parotid pleomorphic adenoma, atypical vascular proliferation in the vocal cords, fat necrosis and inflammation, and active chronic inflammation of the hypopharynx. None of the lesions had necrotic areas on contrast-enhanced diagnostic CT. No adverse reactions to the contrast agent were encountered. Not all of the structures were measured in all subjects because of the limited available coverage of the CTP images.
P Values from analysis of variance
Table 3 summarizes of the results for blood flow, blood volume, MTT, and CP. Measurements in the subcutaneous fat and base of the tongue provided highly variable results ranging from 0 to the highest values. On closer inspection, we frequently observed substantial motion in these areas, which at least partly explained the variability. Minimal repositioning of ROI lead to major changes in the values in the subcutaneous fat, which presumably depended on presence of vascular structures in the ROI. Therefore, measurements in the subcutaneous fat and at the base of the tongue were considered unreliable and excluded from further analysis. As seen in Table 3, muscles had low blood volume, blood flow, and CP and a long MTT. Malignant lesions and muscles clear differed in all measured parameters.
Perfusion CT parameters of different structures and lesions
Unpaired t test analysis showed a significant difference between the malignant lesions and salivary glands in MTT (P = .008) and CP (P = .011), with the normal glands having relatively longer MTT and higher CP. Significant differences were also observed between the malignant and benign lesions in blood flow (P = .032) and especially in MTT (P = .0005), with benign processes having lower blood flows and longer MTTs. In the thyroid gland, MTT was longer than that of malignancies (P = .0007). Blood volumes in the salivary glands, benign lesions, and malignant tumors notably overlapped. Differences in blood volumes between the thyroid gland and malignancies were significant (P = .0004), with the normal thyroid gland having higher volumes.
No malignant lesion had a MTT longer than 5.5 seconds. All lesions with MTT slower than 3.5 seconds were malignant, and malignant lesions with MTT of 3.5–5.5 seconds differed from the nonmalignant lesions by having a CP of less than 25 mL/100 g/min.
Discussion
Perfusion can be defined as the blood flow through a tissue of interest per unit of volume. Our CTP technique was based on the central volume principle, which related blood flow, blood volume, and MTT as follows: blood flow = blood volume/MTT. After an intravenous bolus injection of an iodinated contrast agent, attenuation changes in vessels and tissue can be observed during the first pass by means of rapid (dynamic) image acquisition at a given anatomic level. Time-attenuation curves can then be constructed for reader-defined ROIs. Within the limits of some assumptions, tissue perfusion can be estimated on the basis of the observed attenuation changes: The time course of the iodine concentration is a measure of the regional perfusion, and this concentration is linearly correlated to tissue attenuation values, as seen on CT. Several algorithms and mathematical techniques may be applied to measure tissue perfusion with CT. The deconvolution-based calculation of these parameters is the method we used. Compared with other methods, deconvolution analysis is less sensitive to noise, requires lower injection rates, and is more reliable for measurement of low perfusion values (1, 3, 7, 8). Deconvolution of arterial and tissue enhancement curves is a complex mathematical process that gives the blood flow as the height of the plateau, whereas blood volume is calculated as the area under the curve. The equation MTT = blood volume/blood flow can then be used to obtain the MTT.
With MR imaging, tumor perfusion can be appreciated with a dynamic acquisition of T1- or T2*-weighted images through the tumor after a bolus injection of gadolinium-based contrast material. The pharmacokinetic behavior of gadolinium-based agents is similar to that of iodinated contrast agents. With this method, absolute quantification of tumor perfusion is difficult because signal intensity and the gadolinium concentration are not linearly related (9–12).
CTP applications were almost exclusively conducted for research until a number of CT manufacturers released commercial software packages, facilitating its clinical use. It has found an important role in evaluation of the CNS, especially for evaluating patients with stroke, for assessing the risk of stroke when vascular surgery is planned, and for examining brain tumors (1–7, 8, 12, 13). To our knowledge, only one previous group studied CTP of head and neck squamous cell carcinomas (SCCs) by using the deconvolution method (14), and a few performed compartmental analysis of head and neck SCCs (15–17), as summarized in Table 4. We evaluated one case of rhabdomyosarcoma that had somewhat decreased blood flow, in addition to four cases of SCC.
Values from perfusion CT studies of head and neck squamous cell cancers to date
Our results show that CTP of the head and neck is feasible except at the laryngeal level, at least in some cases. Three of four patients with uninterpretable CTP data had lesions of larynx or hypopharynx, where CTP was severely compromised by breathing and swallowing artifacts. These artifacts are a consequence of a relatively long study time of 50 seconds, and CTP was successful in only two (40%) of five attempted cases at this level. CTP in other areas of the head and neck was not as severely hampered by these artifacts. Poor bolus timing was the cause in the fourth patient, who was one of our first patients; this outcome was likely due to some inexperience.
In most reported studies, CTP was performed with no contrast material in the patients’ system, as it is a hypothetical confounding factor in CTP calculations that may potentially cause underestimation of microvascular permeability (18). In our method, CTP followed routine diagnostic enhanced CT of the neck. Comparison of our values in head and neck SCCs with those in the literature indicated that a preceding contrast-enhanced study may not substantially affect CTP (Table 4). The practical advantage of performing CTP after the routine CT is obvious, as target levels for CTP can be better defined by reviewing the enhanced anatomic images first. In addition, the patient is not subjected to the added radiation of the nonenhanced neck CT, which may be used to plan the levels of coverage for CTP. Performing CTP after routine CT may affect capillary permeability values, however image acquisition times of at least 2 minutes would be needed for adequate assessment of the CP (3).
Some have argued that the ideal arterial input vessel for CTP calculations is the ECA, as head and neck tumors typically derive their blood supply from this vessel. We found no significant difference when the ICA was used instead. In addition, we did not find a significant difference with the arterial input vessels on either side. The ability to use the ICA instead of the ECA makes CTP more robust and adds great flexibility. The ECA is more challenging to define than the ICA, and it is more sensitive to motion artifact, resulting in inaccuracies on CTP. CTP was reproducible, with no significant intrareader or interreader variability.
For normal structures (excluding the thyroid and salivary glands), the blood volume, blood flow, and CP where clearly lower than those for malignant lesions, and all normal structures without exception (including the thyroid and salivary glands) had long MTTs relative to malignant lesions. Excluding the thyroid and salivary glands, we observed significant differences between malignant lesions and normal structures in all four parameters; malignant lesions tended to have higher blood volumes, blood flows, and CPs, but the difference was most reliably seen with MTTs (Figs 1–4). The thyroid and salivary glands had high blood volumes, blood flows, and CPs, with some overlap with values seen in malignant lesions. These structures also had a short MTT relative to those of other anatomic structures and benign lesions, but the MTTs were not as short as observed in malignant tumors.
CPs, blood volumes, and blood flows for benign lesions overlapped those of malignant tumors, but MTT values clearly differed (Figs 1–4). A short MTT reflects high perfusion pressure, which represents relatively high blood flow with relatively low blood volume. This situation indicates a large pool of stagnant blood in the lesion and is likely due to increased capillary leakiness, which may explain why MTTs appeared to be reliable in distinguishing malignant tumors from benign lesions in our study. If this assumption proves true, CP values (along with long imaging times and associated motion artifacts) may possibly not be needed to assess tumor perfusion.
The elevated blood flows, blood volumes, and CPs and the short MTTs in malignant lesions were most probably due to tumor neovascularity. Although blood flow and MTT differed between malignant and benign lesions, our results unexpectedly failed to show a high CP in malignant lesions. The initial presence of contrast medium and the relatively short acquisition times could explain our relatively low CP values in malignant lesions. Gandhi et al (14) commented on the wide range of CPs and postulated that this is due to differing biologic properties of tumors. Comparison of their blood flow, blood volume, and MTT values showed that our standard deviation was smaller, indicating that we did not have such a wide variability in measurements.
Blood volume appears be the major discriminator of disease in the brain, and according to our results, not in the head and neck. This finding may have been due to absence of the blood-brain barrier in the head and neck. Normal brain has a low blood volume, whereas normal salivary glands and thyroid gland have high and very high blood volumes. Mucosal surfaces are also well perfused and could have high blood volumes. Therefore, discrimination of malignant tumors from normal structures (and benign lesions) on the basis of blood volume may not be as reliable in the head and neck as it is in the brain.
Apart from numerical differences, malignant lesions tended to clearly stand out on the color maps (Fig 3), allowing for a quick overview of the whole plane. As with any other functional result, this finding should not be used in isolation, but rather, interpreted in conjunction with the anatomic images.
Some have postulated that relative values are more important than absolute values (14). Although time may prove this to be true, an absolute value is more practical to use. In our patients, no malignant lesion had a MTT longer than 5.5 seconds. All lesions with a MTT of less than 3.5 seconds were malignant, and malignant lesions with an MTT of 3.5–5.5 seconds differed from benign lesions in that they had a CP of less than 25 mL/100 g/min. Reliability of these cutoff values must be evaluated, and we are currently testing this in a prospective study. In addition to testing MTT as a discriminator between benign and malignant processes, we will examine the use of blood flow as a predictor of tumor radiation sensitivity, as others have suggested (15–17, 18, 19). Response to radiation therapy is linked to oxygenation of the target tissue. Tumor perfusion and tumoral oxygen concentration are factors that are usually strongly linked. Although CT-determined primary tumor volume has been shown to be an important predictor of local control for several head and neck cancers, the perfusion rate was found to be independent of tumor volume in that regard as well (11, 12, 18, 19). Some have also postulated that CP might have potential value in predicting the local delivery of chemotherapeutic agents (1–3, 10).
Perfusion parameters seem to overlap for malignant lesions, the salivary glands, and the thyroid gland. This overlap may present a challenge in evaluating malignant lesions invading or arising from these organs. However, these organs are easily identifiable on an anatomic basis, and they are not expected to be a source of confusion as long as the primary lesion of interest is outside them.
The reproducibility of brain CTP studies over time has ranged from 15% to 35% in animal studies, and a single study in patients demonstrated 13% variability between examinations performed 24 hours apart (1, 3). The absolute measurement of perfusion in a normal tissue or tumor depends on the cardiac output, which may vary over time, likely explaining the observed variability. A possible solution that Miles et al (20) proposed is implementation of the standardized perfusion value in which tissue perfusion is scaled by using whole-body perfusion, analogous to standardized uptake value in PET. The calculation of the standardized perfusion value requires the patient’s weight and the dose of contrast medium administered.
CTP might play a role in evaluation of the treated neck, where both CT and MR imaging do not offer sufficient sensitivity and specificity. It could also be helpful in cases in which the benign or malignant nature of the tumor is unclear, sometimes even after pathologic analysis of tissue biopsy samples. Although PET is currently the study of choice, CTP might also be useful in evaluating an unknown primary tumor in patients with metastatic neck lymph nodes. However, for CTP to meet this objective, some technical advances are necessary; the main limiting factor is the small area of coverage currently provided (i.e., only 2 cm in the craniocaudal direction), which may be increased to 4 cm with acquisitions at one-half of the time points (13).
Conclusion
CTP after a routine head and neck enhanced CT is feasible except perhaps in the larynx, where three of five attempts failed. CTP appears to be reproducible with no significant intrareader or interreader variability. Values are also reproducible irrespective of the arterial input vessel selected, they seem comparable to those from studies performed before contrast enhancement for routine diagnostic study. The method appears to have value in distinguishing between benign and malignant processes, primarily on the basis of the short MTT of malignant lesions.
References
- Received July 16, 2004.
- Accepted after revision October 14, 2004.
- Copyright © American Society of Neuroradiology
In this issue
Jump to section
Related Articles
Cited By...
- Total-Body Perfusion Imaging with [11C]-Butanol
- Diagnostic value of CT perfusion imaging for parotid neoplasms
- Biologic Imaging of Head and Neck Cancer: The Present and the Future
- Assessment of Quantitative Perfusion Parameters by Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced Sonography Using a Deconvolution Method: An In Vitro and In Vivo Study
- Quantitative evaluation of viable tissue perfusion changes with contrast-enhanced greyscale ultrasound in a mouse hepatoma model following treatment with different doses of thalidomide
- Perfusion CT in Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Upper Aerodigestive Tract: Long-Term Predictive Value of Baseline Perfusion CT Measurements
- CT Perfusion of Head and Neck Cancer: Why We Should Care versus Why Should We Care!
- CT Perfusion of the Neck: Internal Carotid Artery versus External Carotid Artery as the Reference Artery
- Intra- and Interobserver Agreement and Impact of Arterial Input Selection in Perfusion CT Measurements Performed in Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Upper Aerodigestive Tract
- Response and Progression-Free Survival in Oropharynx Squamous Cell Carcinoma Assessed by Pretreatment Perfusion CT: Comparison with Tumor Volume Measurements
- Early Antiangiogenic Activity of Bevacizumab Evaluated by Computed Tomography Perfusion Scan in Patients with Advanced Hepatocellular Carcinoma